Proton

It has recently become fashionable among “privacy” companies based outside of Switzerland to attack the notion of “Swiss privacy”. Such assertions usually take the line of “Switzerland is not special because it also has X, Y, Z”, and then draw a false equivalence between X, Y, Z and what is happening in the countries these “privacy” companies are based in, (which are often 5-eyes or 14-eyes countries(new window) like the United States or Germany). 

Fair competition vs. honesty

Competition is part of the natural course of business, but dishonestly isn’t. And here’s where the problem lies. Claims such as “Switzerland also has warrantless surveillance”, are simply false and ignore the huge problems in other countries’ privacy laws. For example, the US Congress recently re-approved FISA Section 702, which enables the FBI to conduct 3.4 million warrantless searches per year.

A recent article(new window) on the Tuta blog claimed that Switzerland is no better for privacy than Germany because Swiss law enforcement agencies may assist police from other countries. No one has ever claimed that Swiss privacy is exceptional because Switzerland isolates itself from the rest of the world. What is exceptional are the rules of engagement that Switzerland sets.

For example, Article 271 of the Swiss Criminal Code(new window) forbids any Swiss-based provider from directly interacting with foreign law enforcement under criminal penalty. 

This isn’t to say that the Swiss intelligence agency never cooperates with international organizations. However, the Club de Berne(new window) intelligence-sharing forum that Switzerland is part of has no binding obligations and plays a purely advisory role. It is therefore wrong to compare it to  Germany’s binding obligations under the 14-eyes agreement(new window)NATO intelligence programs(new window), and the European Intelligence and Situation Centre(new window) (EU INTCEN). To falsely equate the two is simply deceptive.

There’s also a big difference between police cooperation via Interpol or Europol and the large-scale intelligence collection performed by the NATO intelligence programs.

Tuta makes the completely unsubstantiated claim that “if you are connecting to a Swiss-based service like Proton from outside of Switzerland your data is being actively collected and shared with other intelligence agencies around the world”. Not only is this completely speculative, but there is also no basis to claim that this is an issue specific to Switzerland. 

Finally, competitors often mention the fact that Swiss banking secrecy was finally weakened in 2018 as an example of how Switzerland is no longer a good place for privacy. But there’s a huge difference between financial data and personal data. If anything, the fact that it took until 2018 and threats to cut Switzerland off from the global financial system to weaken banking secrecy shows how deeply privacy is ingrained into Swiss culture. 

In the final analysis, it seems the only reason non-Swiss companies are attacking Swiss privacy is because Swiss privacy is actually better.

Related articles

Illustration of a QR code inside an envelope with an alert symbol suggesting the code is part of a scam
Quishing works by tricking people into scanning a scam QR code disguised to look legitimate. Here's how to protect yourself from quishing scams.
Can I change my Gmail address without creating a new account?
This article will guide you through several ways you can edit your Gmail address by adding a few small tweaks.
A stylized icon resembling the Google Photos logo with a dark triangular warning sign containing an exclamation mark, representing Google Photos safety issues
Is Google Photos secure to share private pictures? Here's how its protections can fall short — and other options for safer photo sharing.
how to change your email address
Learn how to change your email address across email services, including Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook, and iCloud without risking your data.
Who is responsible for protecting CUI?
  • Privacy guides
This article breaks down CUI, the parties responsible for marking and guarding it, and what goes into keeping it secure.
The cover image for a Proton Pass blog about how to change your Facebook password settings. The image shows the Facebook icon with a password field beneath it and a tick at the end of the password field
Here's a step-by-step guide for how to change or reset your Facebook password settings — and how to create a strong password you'll remember with Proton Pass.